Skip to main content Skip to search Skip to header Skip to footer

Following the example set by the question-and-answer columns in the early Journals, when Mary Baker Eddy was Editor, this column will respond to general queries from Journal readers with responses from Journal readers. You'll find information at the end of the column about how to submit questions.

Why is prophesying an evil?

From the August 2011 issue of The Christian Science Journal

In “A Rule for Motives and Acts” in the Church Manual is the sentence, “The members of this Church should daily watch and pray to be delivered from all evil, from prophesying . . .” (p. 40). Why is prophesying an evil? Jesus as well as Mary Baker Eddy prophesied on occasion.  —A reader in California, US

A: Mary Baker Eddy concludes that sentence with the word erroneously. She was not against genuine prophesying, but the false kind. Her writings exhibit the highest regard for the prophets who based their predictions on a clear understanding of spiritual law. 

Erroneous prophecy is the material reading of physical signs. Matter-based thinking looks only at externals and is blind to the spiritual laws of being. It leads to superstition, which sees prophecy as a mysterious personal gift that can be erratic, enigmatic, and indecisive; whereas true prophecy is useful, understandable, and rests on established laws of being. 

Sign up for unlimited access

You've accessed 1 piece of free Journal content


Subscription aid available

 Try free

No card required

More In This Issue / August 2011


Explore Concord—see where it takes you.

Search the Bible and Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures